Star FactorySusan Boyle dreamed her dream in time gone by, but it was Simon Cowell who made it all possible, let alone worth living.
We don't have a category for Master Manipulator of the Year in this, our annual year-end look at the world of entertainment. If we did, Cowell would win in a heartbeat. Instead, we're anointing him Entertainer of the Year for 2009.
<snip>
DARRYL STERDAN
Simon Cowell? Entertainer of the year? This year? As Simon might say, absolute rubbish.
It might have made an iota of sense a few years ago, when Idol meant something. But ratings-wise, it has peaked. Sure, every year it births a new crop of singers -- almost all flashes in the pan. For every Kelly Clarkson, there's a Ruben Studdard, a Fantasia, a Taylor Hicks.
Besides, arguably the most successful Idol alums didn't win -- Daughtry, Jennifer Hudson, Clay Aiken. That pretty much negates the notion of Cowell as kingmaker, IMHO. And I challenge anyone to name one thing Cowell did this year that was unique and entertaining. He's a savvy businessman, sure.
Bottom line: Decades from now, when Susan Boyle and Adam Lambert are forgotten, everyone will think of 2009 as the year Michael Jackson died. Even Simon.
St. Catherines Standard