AI Season 8: Top 9 - Week of 3-31-09

[Moonshot]

Good night everyone!  Hope to see you all here next Tuesday for the Top 8 at 8!

The show is only ONE HOUR next week!

[claydevotee]

She should have kept in mind that other people--who could be in a position to help her career--are watching this show. She made a fool of herself.

You're right there, SUNNY!   Actually the more I think about it, she may have been intentionally trying to sabotage her career.  Maybe she really doesn't enjoy being on stage and her silliness and giddiness was merely a coping mechanism?????   Will we ever really know?  Do we really even care?

Anyway .....   Thanks, MICHELLE, for your excellent moderating and to everybody who contributes to this thread to make it such a fun place to gather every week!    

[mrs. c.]

Why did lady GaGa have a zipper over her eye and why did Megan caw caw and wave her arms again
Well, I think they got it right this week

[WilsonClaymate]

If she hadn't been so arrogant at the top of the show, he probably would have at least pretended to evaluate her performance.

IMO once she said she didn't care, I think she lost all chances of any consideration from the judges



Michelle -- thanks again for all your input and keeping us informed.

Hope to see all you ladies back here next week.

[Sundancer]

If she hadn't been so arrogant at the top of the show, he probably would have at least pretended to evaluate her performance.

IMO once she said she didn't care, I think she lost all chances of any consideration from the judges

I'm stunned that she would say something so unprofessional. She really shot herself in the foot.

[claydevotee]

Why did lady GaGa have a zipper over her eye  and why did Megan caw caw and wave her arms again

  SHARON.   It was certainly a surreal experience, wasn't it????

[mrs. c.]

Had to add, that I loved the Ford commercial tonight

[claydevotee]

If she hadn't been so arrogant at the top of the show, he probably would have at least pretended to evaluate her performance.

IMO once she said she didn't care, I think she lost all chances of any consideration from the judges

I'm stunned that she would say something so unprofessional. She really shot herself in the foot.

Again, I'm not sure this "unprofessional" behavior was unintentional.  Just a personal theory.....

[mrs. c.]

Why did lady GaGa have a zipper over her eye  and why did Megan caw caw and wave her arms again

  SHARON.   It was certainly a surreal experience, wasn't it????

It was a bit like a circus was Gaga's piano full of pink bubbles too

[claydevotee]

It was a bit like a circus  was Gaga's piano full of pink bubbles too

   Ah, but of course!     

[Sundancer]

If she hadn't been so arrogant at the top of the show, he probably would have at least pretended to evaluate her performance.

IMO once she said she didn't care, I think she lost all chances of any consideration from the judges

I'm stunned that she would say something so unprofessional. She really shot herself in the foot.

Again, I'm not sure this "unprofessional" behavior was unintentional.  Just a personal theory.....

Oh, I don't know that it was unintentional at all. But it made her look immature up there, next to the others--esp. Anoop, who was so poised in the hot seat.

[Sundancer]

USAToday.com:

Next week, we hear songs from the years the contestants were born.

[Pepe]

What a blessing, Megan  has left!!!    I have never seen a contestant act more immature than she did last night.  I wished they would have saved us and not have had her sing, she is horrible!!!!   The judges told her she was pretty to many times and she started believing it and had to always be doing something to draw attention to herself.  How pathetic.  Lady GAGA has a hit record!!  My gosh what is the music industry coming too.  I loved David Cook last night thought he was spectacular and looked mighty good to me!!!!!!!!